Restorative Justice

BMCC Sunday Sermon · 8 Nov 2026

In the deep autumn of 2026, Hong Kong society faced a succession of events that called for deep reflection. The investigation report into the Wang Fuk Court fire had been officially released; the officials involved had resigned, and the Chief Executive along with several senior officials made public apologies. Around the same time, a former senior media figure who had been in detention, was released early and made public statements praising national development—statements that provoked wide discussion across the community. It was in this atmosphere of mingled grief, anger, and searching for meaning that the guest preacher at Blessed Ministry Community Church opened Jonah chapters 3:10 to 4:11 and invited the congregation to wrestle with a question as ancient as it is urgent: in the wake of harm, what does true justice look like?

The story of Jonah is familiar to many—the reluctant prophet swallowed by a great fish, then sent, against his will, to preach judgment to Nineveh. The preacher led the congregation into the historical depth behind this narrative. Nineveh was not merely a city; it was the capital of the Assyrian Empire, the embodiment of imperial power. This was the empire that had invaded Israel, dismantled its nationhood, displaced its people from their own land. The book of Nahum describes Nineveh in stark terms: “Woe to the bloody city, full of lies and plunder.” Against this background, Jonah’s revulsion at the prospect of Nineveh’s salvation was no simple ethnic prejudice—it was the deep wound of a traumatised people. The preacher further noted that even the Samaritans of the New Testament, so often despised by Jewish contemporaries, owed their origins to the Assyrian Empire’s policy of forced resettlement and intermarriage—a legacy of conquest still shaping lives centuries later.

This context illuminates why Jonah fled. The preacher observed that Jonah’s problem was not that he misunderstood God—quite the opposite. He knew God all too well. As Jonah himself declared: “I know that you are a gracious God and merciful, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love, and relenting from disaster.” It was precisely because Jonah understood God’s wide mercy that he did not want to go. He knew that if Nineveh repented, God would forgive them. And to Jonah, that felt profoundly unjust: the oppressor, the aggressor, the destroyer of his nation—repenting and receiving pardon, while his own people had been given no such redemptive second chance. This “unfair grace” was the source of his rage.

At this point, the preacher introduced a crucial distinction: retributive justice versus restorative justice. Retributive justice focuses on punishment—wrongdoers must face consequences for their actions. This instinct has its place and its logic. But the preacher pointed out that punishment alone does not equal the perpetrator’s genuine repentance, nor does it bring healing to the victim. A person may serve their sentence and never truly reckon with the harm they caused; a survivor may witness punishment and still bleed in the dark. Restorative justice reaches further. It seeks genuine acknowledgment of the harm done, the restoration of equal dignity to survivors—giving them a real and honoured voice—and aims at the healing of relationships through confession, apology, and forgiveness. The preacher was careful to note that restorative justice does not mean evading legal accountability. Indeed, a person who is truly repentant should be more willing to accept legal consequence, not less. The church has sometimes made the mistake of allowing “I have confessed before God” to serve as a barrier against earthly accountability—and this, the preacher said, is a misuse of the concept.

The example of Nelson Mandela gave this abstract principle a living face. After his release and election as South Africa’s president, Mandela invited some of the white prison wardens who had once guarded him to serve as his bodyguards—and with characteristic humour, he quipped that since they had watched over him all those years in prison, they might as well continue. Behind that humour lay a profound commitment: to build, through truth-telling, apology, and forgiveness, a new relationship between former oppressors and those they had wronged.

Turning to the Hong Kong situation, the preacher reflected on the response to the Wang Fuk Court fire investigation. The resignation statements of certain officials spoke of “bearing political responsibility” but tended toward expressions of institutional responsibility rather than personal acknowledgment of harm; the voices of survivors did not receive fully equal standing in the process. Some survivors faced significant difficulties in the period that followed. Such a response falls far short of what restorative justice requires. At a broader social level, those who, upon their release from imprisonment, seek to rebuild their lives often encounter significant obstacles in resuming professional life and finding employment. The preacher asked: whatever one’s view of their past circumstances, has society given them a genuine second chance to begin again? Punishment, the preacher argued, should not become an endless mark of exclusion.

The book of Jonah ends with God’s haunting question to the sulking prophet: you cared about a plant that grew and withered in a single night—should I not care about a city of more than 120,000 people who cannot tell their right hand from their left? History records that Nineveh was indeed destroyed in 612 BCE—its repentance, it seems, was not lasting. God’s grace does not come without the expectation of transformation; His mercy does not abolish His justice. The preacher cited Jonah’s own description of God: “slow to anger and great in power, and the Lord will by no means clear the guilty.” Wide mercy and serious accountability are not contradictions in God’s heart. The preacher closed with prayer, asking God to help us—in our personal lives, in our communities, and in society at large—not to remain captive to retributive impulses alone, but to work, in the midst of brokenness, for the kind of restorative justice that brings genuine healing. After a time of silence and reflection, the congregation moved together into the Lord’s Table.

Blessed Ministry Community Church (BMCC) is a church that welcomes all people, with open arms especially for those navigating questions of faith, gender, and belonging. If you are carrying the weight of harm or injustice, if you are searching for a space where faith and social justice are taken seriously together, you are warmly welcomed to come and walk with us. This is a home for all who come.